by hook or by crook
1991, Fort Douglas, Wisconsin. Something is snatching children from their beds, and the Winchesters are on the hunt. John doesn't come home one night, Dean is fed up with everything, and in the morning, Sam is gone.
The only lead is the old woman in an old house who told Dean a story about the most wonderful, magical land and the way through the stars, and Dean think he's found pixie dust on the window sill. Dean makes a promise to find Sammy before Dad gets back, and if that means strong arming the boy who never grows up into taking him along, than that's exactly what he'll do.
Second star to the right and straight on 'til morning is a terrible time for Dean to figure out that he hates flying.